Home/Documents/Closing Disclosure

Is this closing disclosure real? Check for edits and AI fakes

A closing disclosure is the standardised statement of what a mortgage will cost, delivered to the borrower before closing. Its fixed layout and internal maths make it hard to alter unnoticed: the interest rate, the annual percentage rate, the projected payments, and the cash to close all have to agree. An APR lower than the note rate, or a cash-to-close figure that is not the sum of its lines, marks a document that was edited rather than generated.

Last updated:

Most edited
  • interest rate and APR
  • cash to close
  • projected payments
  • loan amount
Reviewed by
Mortgage underwriters, closing agents, and compliance reviewers

Forgery methods seen on a closing disclosure

  1. Rate and APR edits

    The interest rate is lowered to improve affordability, or the APR is left unchanged after the rate moved. On a fixed-rate loan without a buydown, an APR below the stated rate is arithmetically impossible and a direct sign of alteration.

  2. Cash to close adjustment

    The funds required at closing are reduced to hide how much the borrower must bring. The itemised lines on the earlier pages then fail to sum to the printed figure.

  3. Payment understatement

    Projected monthly payment is trimmed to fit a debt-to-income limit. It stops matching the loan amount, rate, and term stated on the same page.

  4. Mismatch with the loan estimate

    Figures are changed on one document and not the other, or the disclosure is assembled from a template with different fee sections. Comparison between the two forms shows changes no lender would make.

Closing disclosure fraud: your questions answered

How do mortgage underwriters check a closing disclosure?

They compare it with the loan estimate and the approval, verify the arithmetic on cash to close and monthly payments, and confirm that the APR is consistent with the rate. Forensic review of the PDF tests whether numbers were altered after the form was generated.

What can be edited on a closing disclosure?

Most often the interest rate, monthly payment, cash to close, and the loan amount. Each has knock-on figures elsewhere on the form, so changing one without the others leaves detectable contradictions.

Can the APR be lower than the interest rate?

On a fixed-rate loan without a buydown, no. The APR takes the nominal rate and adds the effect of prepaid finance charges, which can only raise the figure. Adjustable-rate loans and temporary buydowns are the exceptions, because their APR is a composite of rates over the loan's life.

What is the difference between a loan estimate and a closing disclosure?

The loan estimate is the early, non-binding statement of expected terms and costs, given after application. The closing disclosure is the final statement, provided before closing. Both use standard layouts, and material differences between them should be explainable.

Which forensic checks matter most for a closing disclosure?

On a closing disclosure, the review prioritises the APR against the interest rate, the cash-to-close arithmetic, and consistency from page to page. The rest of a closing disclosure is covered by the general pixel, font and metadata layers.

What inconsistency most often exposes a forged copy of a closing disclosure?

Usually a disagreement between the loan amount and rate and the projected principal and interest payment. On a closing disclosure both come from one production pass, so an edit that touches one and not the other shows.

Where does fraud show up in a closing disclosure?

In the figures that decide a transaction: interest rate and APR, cash to close, and projected payments. The layout is genuine or well copied, so the edit sits in one line that the rest of a closing disclosure is meant to support.

Can the numbers on a closing disclosure agree and still be fake?

Yes. Recalculated figures stay internally consistent. Cross-document comparison and pixel analysis matter because they test what recalculation cannot fix: the history of interest rate and APR in the file and the other documents behind a closing disclosure.

How much does it cost to check a closing disclosure with TamperCheck?

One check on a closing disclosure is one document charge, with no subscription, seat fee or minimum. Your first document is on us, so you can test it on a closing disclosure you already hold before committing.

What to expect on a genuine closing disclosure before you test it

The form runs to five pages. It sets out the loan terms (amount, rate, monthly principal and interest, and whether these can change), projected payments including taxes and insurance, and costs at closing. Later pages itemise loan costs and other costs, compute cash to close, and give the finance charge, total of payments, APR, and total interest percentage. The lender, settlement agent, and property details close the form.

Several relationships can be tested from the page. Cash to close equals total closing costs less lender credits plus the down payment and other adjustments. Monthly principal and interest follow from amount, rate, and term. For a closed-end loan the APR is at least the interest rate, because it folds in prepaid finance charges. The total interest percentage is total interest over the loan divided by the loan amount.

What looks wrong on a closing disclosure

  • Interest rate and APR that do not sit with the figures around it

    The interest rate and APR are the figure a forger most wants to change. Read it against the other amounts on the page and against any second document that should agree with it. A careless edit updates this line and leaves the rest of the file describing the original.

  • A cash to close that reads right but renders oddly

    Zoom in on the cash to close and look at the background behind the characters. Edits often leave a faint halo, a patch of slightly different texture or spacing that was fine at full-page view.

  • A lender name or branch that does not match the facility

    Check the lender, branch and loan reference against how the same lender formats them elsewhere.

  • Payoff or closure dates that precede the last payment

    Look for a closure or payoff that predates the final instalment, or amounts that ignore interest accrued.

  • Fees and rates that were never part of the product

    Charges, margins or rate resets that do not match the product the lender actually sells point to a document built from a template.

A practical checklist for a closing disclosure

  1. 1. Check the fields against each other

    Read interest rate and APR, cash to close, and projected payments together rather than one at a time. Forgers typically change one value and leave the rest of the document describing the original.

  2. 2. Inspect the file metadata

    Open the document properties and look at the producer, creation date, and modification date. A document produced by a consumer PDF editor, or created long after the date printed on its face, is worth a closer look.

  3. 3. Ask for a second document

    Request a corroborating document from the same issuer or an adjacent period. Forgery effort concentrates on one file, so inconsistencies surface as soon as there are two to compare.

  4. 4. Run a forensic check

    Manual review catches obvious edits but not field-level pixel manipulation or synthetic generation. TamperCheck runs 300+ forensic checks on a closing disclosure and returns a risk score from 0 to 100 within seconds, on published per-document pricing.

Inside the forensic analysis of a closing disclosure

  • Arithmetic reconciliation

    Stated totals are recomputed from their components, and running or cumulative figures are checked for continuity across periods. A single edited value breaks the chain even when the page still looks right.

  • Table structure integrity

    Inserted and deleted rows leave structural artifacts behind: inconsistent spacing, misaligned columns, and formatting the visible table no longer accounts for.

  • Field-level forensics

    Every text region is analysed in its own right rather than as part of one whole-page image. This catches the smoothed and feathered edits that whole-image Error Level Analysis misses entirely.

  • And many more checks

    The three above are the layers that carry the most weight on a closing disclosure. Every upload runs the full suite of 300+ checks regardless of document class, spanning file structure and metadata, pixel-level forensics, font and text rendering, optical and print characteristics, provenance signals, AI-generation signatures, and many more checks.

Check a document

Upload a PDF or a photo of closing disclosure. TamperCheck returns a risk score from 0 to 100 and marks the region that was edited, usually within seconds.

For developers, the API class is closing_disclosure. See the API and MCP documentation.

Often checked alongside

All supported document types