# Koncile vs TamperCheck.ai: named findings vs. a semantic risk score

> Both look at invoices, bank statements, payslips and tax documents. Koncile bundles fraud detection with data extraction on EU-hosted infrastructure and hands back a risk score. TamperCheck does one thing: verification. You get the specific field that was altered, not a number you have to interpret.

**Canonical URL:** https://tampercheck.ai/compare/koncile-vs-tampercheck-ai

---

## Bottom line

Koncile extracts data and checks for fraud in the same call, returning a 0-to-1 risk score from EU-hosted infrastructure. TamperCheck skips extraction entirely and goes straight to the forensic question: which field was altered, and where? 300+ layers, a dedicated AI-generation pass, 200+ document types from 190+ countries. Nothing retained.

## TamperCheck.ai vs Koncile: 19 questions

| | TamperCheck.ai | Koncile |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Documents covered | 200+ document types from 190+ countries | B2B finance and identity: invoices, statements, payslips, cheques, passports |
| Forensic checks per document | 300+ forensic layers on every upload | Forensic analysis plus ML and semantic business-rule checks |
| AI-generated documents | Dedicated synthesis pass, resolved to the field | Detects tampered, forged and AI-generated documents (their claim) |
| Image forgery detection | Pixel-level: splice, resave and edge-sharpness deltas | Part of the forensic layer; depth not published |
| PDF & file structure | Objects, fonts, metadata and editor traces | Yes, alongside metadata |
| Malware & file safety scanning | On every upload | Not advertised |
| Digital signature certificates | Trust chain, revocation and edits made after signing | Not published |
| Email files (.eml, .msg) | DKIM signature checked, every attachment analysed | Not published |
| E-invoice cross-check | Embedded Factur-X / ZUGFeRD / UBL XML vs the printed invoice | Not published |
| Field-level alteration | Yes - the altered field named and located | No - a 0-to-1 risk score for the document |
| Scans, photos & physical marks | Stamps, embossing, signatures, print artefacts | Handwriting and skewed scans handled, for extraction |
| Automated QC on findings | Every finding re-validated before you see it | Not published |
| What you get back | A verdict, the field named, in plain English | A 0-to-1 risk score, with extraction in the same call |
| Time to verdict | Within seconds, unattended | Not published |
| Price per document | Per document, published | Fraud detection uses 2 credits per page; about EUR 0.40 monthly or EUR 0.36 annual on Advanced |
| Commitment | None - no seat fees, no minimum, no cap | Advanced from EUR 199/mo monthly or EUR 179/mo annual, with 1,000 credits |
| How you start | Self-serve - first document on us, live the same day | Self-serve app and API on Advanced; 20 free extraction credits |
| Document retention | Zero - analysed in memory, never written to disk | Stored in the EU - AWS Paris, DR in Frankfurt. SOC 2 Type II, HDS |
| Training on your documents | Never | Not addressed in published material |

*Source note: koncile.ai - product and pricing pages, checked November 2026*

### Sources

- [Koncile document AI platform](https://www.koncile.ai/en)
- [Koncile pricing](https://www.koncile.ai/en/pricing)

## When to choose TamperCheck

- You need **the field, not a score**. A 0.82 tells you how worried to be. Naming the altered figure tells you what to do about it.
- **Nothing should be stored, period.** EU hosting answers where documents live. Zero retention makes the question go away entirely.
- Your documents go **well beyond B2B finance** - identity documents, credentials, tenancy agreements, medical records from 190+ countries.
- You already have extraction running. Adding a second IDP platform for the fraud module is more consolidation than the problem needs.
- **Digital signatures are verified, not just displayed.** When a document carries one, we resolve the certificate itself: who issued it, whether that issuer is on a trusted list, and whether the chain is complete.

## When to choose Koncile

- **You need extraction and fraud in one contract.** Koncile turns documents into structured data and checks them. We don't extract, by design. If you have no pipeline at all and want both in one call, their combined shape covers more ground on day one.
- **Your contract names EU residency specifically.** ISO 27001-certified hosting in France with HDS answers the question on paper. Zero retention also closes it - but some procurement templates want the certificate, not the outcome.
- Your fraud is mostly **semantic** - wrong tax rates, totals that don't reconcile, supplier logic - and you want that as the primary control.
- **Extraction and fraud in one self-serve plan.** Koncile's Advanced tier includes 1,000 credits and app/API access. Fraud detection costs 2 credits per page, which makes its public rate about EUR 0.40 on monthly billing or EUR 0.36 on annual billing before any unused allowance.

## Two different answers to the same question

Koncile makes a good argument: AI-generated fakes are pixel-perfect, so the tell has to be **logical** - totals that don't add up, tax rates that are wrong, values that contradict business rules. Sound reasoning. We run the same class of arithmetic and cross-field checks. The difference: we treat them as one part of a 300+ layer forensic stack, not the headline. Because a smoothed pixel-level edit to a single figure can still reconcile perfectly and needs catching another way.

The clearer decision is **scope**. Koncile is a document platform: extraction plus fraud, aimed at finance and procurement teams. TamperCheck is deliberately one thing. If you have no document pipeline and want extraction and fraud bundled, their shape covers more ground today. Most teams already extract. For them, the only question left is how deep the forensic layer goes.

On **residency**, it helps to be precise about what you actually need. Koncile offers EU-hosted, certified storage. TamperCheck offers no storage at all. If the requirement is "documents must remain in the EU," they answer it. If it's "documents must not be retained," we do.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the best Koncile alternative for document fraud detection?

TamperCheck.ai, if you need the forensic layer rather than a full document platform. Koncile bundles extraction with fraud scoring for B2B finance. TamperCheck covers 200+ document types from 190+ countries, names the altered field instead of returning a score, and never stores the document.

### Is a risk score or a named field better for fraud review?

A score tells an analyst how worried to be. A named field tells them what to do. When a decline has to be explained to a customer or defended in a complaint file, "the net pay figure is rendered in a different font weight" carries the decision. A 0.82 doesn't.

### Does TamperCheck detect AI-generated documents that reconcile correctly?

Yes - that's exactly what forensic depth exists for. A generated document can be internally consistent and arithmetically perfect, so logical checks pass it. TamperCheck compares each field's rendering against the rest of its own page - font weight, kerning, edge sharpness, recompression history - and runs a separate AI-generation pass on every upload.

---

Pricing: https://tampercheck.ai/pricing.md · API docs: https://tampercheck.ai/docs · Site index for AI tools: https://tampercheck.ai/llms.txt
