# Is This Email Legit? How to Verify an Email and Its Attachments Before You Act on It

> A forwarded email or screenshot can be edited in seconds. Learn how to check the original email file for edits after sending, fake senders and altered attachments.

*Published 2026-11-17 · 7 min read · TamperCheck.ai*

Canonical: https://tampercheck.ai/blog/is-this-email-legit-verify-email-and-attachments

---
More and more of the proof you are asked to trust arrives as an email. A loan applicant forwards their job offer. A customer sends a "payment sent" confirmation. A supplier emails an invoice with new bank details. Each of these is easy to fake, and a screenshot or a forward makes it easier still.

The good news: the original email file usually carries enough evidence to tell you whether the message was changed, who really sent it, and whether the attached documents were edited. This guide shows you what to look for, and how TamperCheck now checks email files for you.

## Key takeaways

- **Screenshots and forwards prove nothing.**: Anyone can change the text of an email before taking a screenshot or forwarding it. Ask for the original email file instead.
- **Most emails carry a hidden seal.**: Most email providers add a digital signature (DKIM) when they send a message. If the body changes afterwards, the seal no longer matches.
- **Senders and dates can be checked.**: Look-alike addresses, reply-to addresses that point somewhere else, brand-new domains and back-dated messages all leave traces in the headers.
- **The attachment matters as much as the email.**: A genuine email can still carry an edited payslip or invoice, so every attachment needs its own check.

## Why "is this email legit?" is now a business question

Most advice on fake emails is about phishing: don't click the link. Businesses face a different problem. The email *is* the evidence, and someone has a reason to change it.

- **Lending and tenancy:** an applicant forwards an offer letter or salary confirmation with a higher figure.
- **Accounts payable:** a "fake invoice email" swaps the supplier's bank details, or arrives from a domain one letter away from the real one.
- **Marketplaces and merchants:** a buyer sends a "payment completed" email that was never sent by the payment provider.
- **Claims and disputes:** a back-dated email is offered as proof that notice was given in time.

In every case, what you see in your inbox (or in a screenshot of someone else's inbox) is only what the sender wants you to see.

## Step 1: Ask for the original email file, not a screenshot

A screenshot is a picture, and a forward is a fresh message written by the person forwarding it. Neither keeps the original seal or the original headers. The original file does.

Every major email app can save one:

- **Gmail:** open the email, click the three-dot menu, then **Download message** (.eml).
- **Outlook on the web:** three-dot menu, then **Save** or **Download** (.eml).
- **Outlook for Windows or Mac:** drag the email to your desktop, or **File > Save As** (.msg on Windows, .eml on Mac).
- **Apple Mail:** **File > Save As**, choose **Raw Message Source**, and save with a .eml ending.

> **TIP:** If someone refuses to send the original file and will only send a screenshot or a forward, treat that as a signal in its own right.

## Step 2: Check whether the email was edited after it was sent

When a provider such as Gmail or Microsoft 365 sends a message, it usually signs it with **DKIM**: a cryptographic seal over the message body and key headers. The seal includes a fingerprint of the body. If a single character of the body changes later, such as an amount, a date or a name, the fingerprint no longer matches.

That is the strongest check you can run on an email, and it needs the original file.

There are honest reasons a seal can break, and a good check has to tell them apart from an edit:

- mailing lists that add a footer
- corporate security gateways that rewrite links
- mail servers that convert the message format in transit

TamperCheck treats those cases as "changed in transit", a note for a reviewer to look at, and only treats a broken seal as evidence of an edit when none of them explain it.

## Step 3: Check who really sent it

Even an unedited email can come from the wrong person. Look at:

- **The real sender address**, not the display name. "HSBC Payments" can sit on top of any address.
- **Look-alike domains**: `paypa1.com`, `hsbc-secure.co`, or an extra word added to a real company name.
- **Reply-To and Return-Path**: a genuine-looking From address with a reply address that quietly points somewhere else is a classic invoice-fraud pattern.
- **Domain age**: a domain registered days before the email, or *after* the date it claims, is a strong sign of an impostor.
- **Disposable mailboxes**: throwaway email services have no place in a supplier or employer relationship.

## Step 4: Check the dates

Every server that handles an email adds a timestamped `Received` line. The first one shows when the message actually left the sender's side. Compare it with the `Date` shown in the email. A large gap, or a `Date` earlier than the message could possibly have been sent, points to a back-dated message.

You can do this yourself with our free [Email Header Analyzer](https://tampercheck.ai/tools/email-header-analyzer). Paste the raw headers to see who sent the message, where replies and bounces go (with look-alike warnings), each server hop with its delay, and the SPF, DKIM and DMARC results explained in plain language. It runs in your browser, and nothing is uploaded. It reads the result your mail server recorded; it does not re-check the seal itself. For that, use the full email check below.

## Step 5: Check every attachment

Fraudsters have learned that a genuine email is the best way to deliver a forged document. The email can pass every check while the attached payslip, bank statement or invoice was edited before it was attached.

So the attachments need the same scrutiny as any document uploaded on its own: file history, font and layout consistency, arithmetic, QR codes, and digital signatures.

**Check an email file in one upload**. Upload a .eml or .msg file. We check the seal, the sender, the dates and every PDF or image attached to it. Your first check is free. (https://tampercheck.ai)

## What's new: email checks in TamperCheck

This week we added email files as a supported upload in the dashboard and the API. Upload a `.eml` or `.msg` file and you get:

- **Edited after sending:** the DKIM body seal is recomputed against the message you received.
- **Sender checks:** look-alike From, Reply-To and Return-Path addresses, disposable mailboxes, and how long ago the sender's domain was registered.
- **Date checks:** the `Date` header compared with when the message was actually sent and delivered.
- **Recorded security results:** the SPF, DKIM and DMARC results the receiving server recorded, including failures that never show in your inbox.
- **Every attachment checked:** each PDF or image attachment runs through the full document check as its own job. The email's verdict reflects the worst result across the email and its attachments.

**Pricing:** an email counts as one check, and each attachment is billed as its own document. The full list of signals is on the [email tampering detection](https://tampercheck.ai/email-tampering-detection) page.

## Frequently asked questions

### How can I tell if an email is legit?

Ask for the original email file (.eml or .msg) rather than a screenshot or a forward. Then check whether its DKIM seal still matches the body, whether the sender and reply-to domains are real and not brand new, and whether the dates in the headers agree. Check any attachments separately.

### Can a forwarded email be edited?

Yes. When you forward an email you are writing a new message, and you can change any of the quoted text before sending. A forward carries none of the original seal, so it cannot prove what the first email said.

### What is DKIM and why does it matter?

DKIM is a digital signature that most email providers add when they send a message. It covers the message body and key headers. If the body is changed after sending, the signature no longer matches, which is how an edited email can be detected.

### Does a failed DKIM check always mean the email was faked?

No. Mailing lists, security gateways and some mail servers change messages in transit and break the seal for honest reasons. A failed seal is a reason to look closer, not a verdict on its own.

### How do I spot a fake invoice email?

Compare the sender's domain letter by letter with the supplier's real domain, check where replies go, look up when the domain was registered, and confirm any change of bank details by phone using a number you already have. Then check the attached invoice itself for edits.
